Printed from the blog of Lori Greene, AHC/CDC, CCPR, FDAI
Allegion
Email: lori_greene@allegion.com, Blog: www.idighardware.com or www.ihatehardware.com


Feb 23 2015

Lock Functions for Classrooms – Pros and Cons

Category: Locks & Keys,School SecurityLori @ 2:19 pm Comments (11)
Share

On February 12th, the Sandy Hook Advisory Commission released the draft of their final report, presented to Connecticut State Governor Dannel P. Malloy.  The report includes many recommendations to improve school security, including several related to locks / physical security:

RECOMMENDATION NO. 1:
The SSIC Report includes a standard requiring classroom and other safe-haven areas to have doors that can be locked from the inside. The Commission cannot emphasize enough the importance of this recommendation. The testimony and other evidence presented to the Commission reveals that there has never been an event in which an active shooter breached a locked classroom door.  [LG: Locked classroom doors have been breached by breaking the glass, but not by defeating the lock.]  Accordingly, the Commission reiterates its recommendation that all classrooms in K-12 schools should be equipped with locked doors that can be locked from the inside by the classroom teacher or substitute.
RECOMMENDATION NO. 2:
The Commission also reiterates its recommendation that all exterior doors in K-12 schools be equipped with hardware capable of implementing a full perimeter lockdown.
RECOMMENDATION NO. 3:
A feasibility study should be conducted to develop additional safety standards concerning the issuance of classroom keys to substitute teachers.

Indicator LockThe report does not state specifically how this locking is to be accomplished, which gives schools some flexibility.  But with so many options available, it can be hard for facility personnel to make that choice.  I’ve spoken to quite a few people about this lately – law enforcement, fire marshals, school security consultants, facility managers and other school personnel, and each of them made a really good case for their lock function of choice.  A few things they all agreed on…the lock must be lockable from within the classroom, AND must allow authorized access by staff and first responders from the ingress side, AND must allow free egress from within the classroom.

But which lock function is best for classroom doors?  There are pros and cons to each:

Classroom Security Function

Pros:  The outside lever can be locked from within the classroom, only by a staff member with a key.  An unauthorized person will not be able to lock the classroom door if they don’t have access to the key.

Cons:  Use of the key to initiate a lockdown requires the staff member to find the key, insert it in the lock, and turn it in the right direction.  This can be difficult during an emergency situation, as fine motor skills may be compromised.  If school staff have not repeatedly practiced locking the door with the key, they may be confused about how to lock the door or whether the door is actually locked.  An indicator can help to overcome that uncertainty.

Entrance / Office Function

Pros:  It is very easy to lock the outside lever, by turning a thumbturn or pushing a button on the inside lever handle of the lock.

Cons:  Anyone is able to lock the door, including someone who may want to secure a classroom to commit an assault, theft, vandalism, or sexual assault.  There are hundreds of thousands of these crimes committed in schools each year.

Storeroom or Standard Classroom Function (kept locked)

Pros:  Often for budgetary reasons, existing locks may be kept in the locked position at all times.  If the door is closed, the door is locked.

Cons:  This can be inconvenient if the door is kept closed and students need to enter the room after class begins.  In the case of classroom locks which could be left unlocked, procedures must be followed to ensure that the outside lever is always kept locked.

Electronic Classroom Lock

Pros:  Pressing a button on a fob worn by staff members can be used to lock the door.  This removes the concern about the fine motor skills require for inserting and turning a key, but does require staff to wear the fob.  Lockdown cannot be initiated by an unauthorized person who is not in possession of the fob.

Cons:  The cost of replacing existing locks with an electronic product may not be feasible for all facilities.

What other pros and cons can you think of with regard to these functions (leave a comment below)?  And how about a poll…

11 Responses to “Lock Functions for Classrooms – Pros and Cons”

  1. Bruce Knott says:

    what about a combination classroom security and Entrance/Office solution. There are locks that are used for students that are unstable and need to be isolated for a time. The idea is that a momentary lock function is available so that as long as a teacher is holding the lock it is secure. When the teacher released the lock it is disabled. If a manual thumb turn with a spring action is initiated from inside the room, this can be a immediate locking of the door while the teacher takes the time needed to use the key to permanently lock the door. Then the key would also be needed to unlock the door so that a student couldn’t fall prey to the coercing of a predator to open the door and violate school policy.
    This also keeps the door from being locked by a non-violent sexual predator. He would not be able to keep the door locked without the use of a key.
    Thank you

  2. Lapointe says:

    Elected government lockdown rooms use a independent dedicated deadlock. Is that not being considered to save money?

  3. Jack Ostergaard says:

    Thanks for the great list and analysis of the various options. I’ve presented most of these arguments to school administrators when we need to decide which one to pick for their project. And all but the more expensive electronic lock down have been chosen. The most important part of the whole system is teaching the participants how to use it. Locking by a credentialed person (classroom security & electronic) doesn’t work if the person is not required to have their credential with them at all times. Interior (classroom side) locks need to have a common (cross)key – not a match to the corridor side. Locks with thumb turns work but students need to know that prank locking has serious consequences. Same problem with the storeroom function.

  4. Louise says:

    With an interior key such as Sargent 10G38 I noticed that you need good eyes to immediately know which way to turn the key.
    If you go with the interior key, be sure it’s abundantly clear which way to turn to lock.
    Don’t confuse me when I’m in panic mode. Just clearly show me which way.
    (in my neck of the woods I see lots of doors with black marker on the doors indicating which way to turn the key.)

  5. Louise says:

    good thing we have an in-house print shop.
    those stickers are $1.00 each without shipping charges.

Leave a Reply

*