Printed from the blog of Lori Greene, AHC/CDC, CCPR, FDAI
Allegion
Email: lori_greene@allegion.com, Blog: www.idighardware.com or www.ihatehardware.com


Jan 24 2018

WW: Another School Shooting

Category: Egress,School SecurityLori @ 1:39 pm Comments (6)
Share

As another school shooting occurs, I struggle with what to write.  Today is Wednesday, the day that I typically post a photo that leaves me wordless – usually a code violation or a particularly creative modification.  I can’t post a Wordless Wednesday photo and ignore yesterday’s school shooting at Marshall County High School, but what’s left to say?

By now you’ve all heard the news about the shooting – two 15-year-old students killed, more than a dozen injuries, another student in custody who will be charged with murder and assault.  Everyone is asking “why?” and “how can we prevent this from happening again?”

I can’t answer those questions.  In the big picture, physical security plays a small role, and will not solve the problem.  But physical security is my area of focus, and I can point out a few things about what reportedly happened yesterday:

  • As with so many school shootings, the shooter was a student.  Although you often hear about concerns regarding “intruders,” students are the most frequent perpetrators of school shootings (refer to the statistics in this article from Campus Safety).  It’s important to consider this when selecting security methods, because if doors can be secured by anyone, they can be secured by a student who intends to commit a crime.
  • During the shooting, many students evacuated and went to safe locations outside of the school.  State officials spoke about the principles of Run-Hide-Fight.  The free egress provided by code-compliant exits allowed the evacuation to occur.  Securing these doors in a manner that deters egress can increase the casualties.  Although in this case the shooter reportedly ran out of ammunition, some students were injured by other students trying to escape.  These injuries could have been compounded if doors were not immediately available for egress.
  • Some students left the common area where the shooting occurred and sheltered in classrooms.  Doors were locked and/or barricaded with furniture.  I checked the websites of the Kentucky State Fire Marshal and the Kentucky Center for School Safety, and did not find any evidence that they allow classroom barricade devices.  Code-compliant classroom security allows doors to be secured quickly, and evacuation to occur if/when needed.
  • In 2013, the Kentucky legislature approved a bill addressing school security, that includes requirements for the front entrance to be controlled electronically or with a greeter, and states: “If a classroom is equipped with hardware that allows the door to be locked from the outside but opened from the inside, the door should remain locked during instruction time.”  This seems to indicate that classroom doors must allow free egress.  The code enforced by the state fire marshal is NFPA 101, which also mandates free egress.

As more information is released in the days to come, perhaps there will be more to learn that can help schools to be prepared.  Feel free to share any thoughts in the reply box.

Graphic: WSMV

6 Responses to “WW: Another School Shooting”

  1. Zeke says:

    Nicely stated Lori.

  2. Tony Klagenberg says:

    NY times carried a story that this is the 11th school shooting (including self inflicted) this year in the USA. Maybe it is time for metal detectors at main entrance or TSA style screenings. How do we keep weapons out of the schools?

  3. Mojo Arch says:

    There was school shooting in Texas the day before this one. Fortunately the young girl who was shot 4 times did not die. Here is the story: https://www.nbcdfw.com/news/local/Teen-Charged-in-North-Texas-High-School-Shooting-470742483.html

  4. Daniel Poehler says:

    Schools can be designed with metal detectors and placed so that egress routes are clear, free and open. Security personnel would have bullet resistant partitions and have concealed weapons. Money is always an obstacle, but priorities must be set. Many other deterrent elements can be incorporated with low cost and maintenance features. Security is not limited to door hardware.

    • Lori says:

      I agree that security is not limited to door hardware. But I think it is very sad that we need metal detectors and bullet resistance partitions in schools. 🙁

      – Lori

  5. Mark says:

    To your point Lori, we can address the physical part of security, but are we getting to the root cause of the violence? Here is a link to a Simon Sinek video that speaks to the Isolation of so many of the shooters
    https://www.google.com/#q=simon+sinek+school+shootings
    Another video is from Malcolm Gladwell that speaks to the act of violence from a different, but related perspective.
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=27aWHudLmgs
    For me, the two seemed unrelated at first, but as I thought about the isolation piece and then put it together with the threshold theory from Gladwell, it began to make more sense that each shooting seems to trigger more…

Leave a Reply